Repair Costs
When it comes to ownership costs, the Honda Pilot edges out slightly with an average annual repair cost of $542, compared to the Acura MDX at $571 per year.
Reliability
- Honda Pilot: Rated at 3.5 out of 5.0 for reliability, it ranks 13th among midsize SUVs. It has lower-than-average ownership costs, though repairs might be more frequent.
- Acura MDX: Scores a solid 4.0 out of 5.0, placing 2nd among luxury midsize SUVs. It boasts average repair costs with infrequent major issues.
Owner Reviews
- Honda Pilot: Owners praise its reliability despite some minor frequent repairs. It has garnered positive feedback across 43 reviews.
- Acura MDX: Known for its luxury and fewer critical issues, it impresses with 32 reviews highlighting its reliability and comfort.
Vehicle Details
Both the Acura MDX and Honda Pilot are midsize SUVs offering three-row seating, designed by Honda but catering to different markets.
- Engine Performance: MDX offers more power options with up to 321 horsepower in the Sport Hybrid, while the Pilot maintains a robust 280 horsepower from a single engine option.
- Cargo Capacity: The Pilot outshines with 83.8 cubic feet of space, compared to the MDX’s 71.6 cubic feet, due to its more boxy design.
- Price Point: The MDX, as a luxury option, starts higher in price compared to the more economical Pilot, even when fully loaded.
Conclusion
Choosing between the Honda Pilot and Acura MDX boils down to your preference for luxury, power options, cargo space, and budget considerations. Whether you prioritize a reliable, family-friendly SUV with economical repair costs (Pilot) or seek the added luxury and power options (MDX), both vehicles offer robust choices in the competitive midsize SUV market.